When thinking about how to review Make Up For Ever’s Aqua Black Waterproof Cream Eye Shadow I could only think about comparing it against MAC’s Fluidline in Blacktrack. I find the two products virtually interchangeable. If you have Fluidline in Blacktrack you don’t need this in your life.
Check out my comparison below:
Both products are creamy and very pigmented.
Both products can be used as liners or as cream shadows.
MUFE calls their cream eye shadow “waterproof.” MAC calls their Fluidline “long-wearing” and “smudge-proof.”
MUFE’s cream shadow sets quicker than MAC’s Fluidline.
MUFE’s cream shadow is denser than MAC’s Fluidline.
MUFE’s cream shadow costs $22 for 0.24 oz. MAC’s Fluidline costs $15 for 0.1 oz.
MUFE’s cream shadow is more pigmented than MAC’s Fluidline in Blacktrack.
In a smudge test, MAC’s Fluidline in Blacktrack held up perfectly while MUFE’s cream shadow did come off a little bit.
MUFE Aqua Black, MAC Fluidline in Blacktrack
Tried Make Up For Ever’s Aqua Black? Share your review in a comment below.
Note: Reviews are solely MY OPINION and based on MY personal experience with the product(s) mentioned.